Results from four binding polls

[Daetrin[Admin]]

All - sorry for the delay in posting the results but I've finally gotten around to it (C5/CRL's ate up a lot of time). They are:

 

BINDING POLL: SE-14R on which costumes

Visual References (ANH Hero) : passed with 92% in favor.

Any film canon (ANH Stunt, ESB, ROTJ) : split 50/50.

Any EU (Commander, Incinerator) : passed with 56% in favor.

 

Actions:

Official CRL for ANH Hero now includes SE-14R as an approved option.

Official CRL's for EU costumes have been updated to allow SE-14R in lieu of the E-11.

Official CRL's for ANH Stunt, ESB, and ROTJ are not updated.

 

 

BINDING POLL: Lightsabers and TK's

OK for ANH Troopers : failed with 73% against

OK for film canon (ESB/ROTJ): failed with 77% against

OK for EU (Commander, Incinerator) : passed with 70% in favor.

 

Actions:

Official CRL's for EU costumes have been updated to allow white light saber in lieu of the E-11.

Official CRL's for ANH Stunt, ANH Hero, ESB, and ROTJ are not updated.

 

 

BINDING POLL : Splitting the ANH EIB criteria in two

"Should the ANH EIB be split to match the CRL?" : failed with 60% against

 

Actions: None

 

 

BINDING POLL: Space Packs

Q: What types of film canon should be allowed?

A: Best effort for film canon (18 votes [100.00%])

 

Q: What types of action figure packs should be allowed?

A: Split

* Exact copy of a particular action figure (9 votes [50.00%])

* Rough copy of either action figure (9 votes [50.00%])

 

Q: Which TK's should be allowed space packs?

Per visual references only (10 votes [55.56%]) (majority vote)

 

THUS

* Best effort film canon packs are allowed.

* Exact or Rough copy of action figure packs are allowed

* This will be an option for ANH stunt costumes only

 

ACTIONS:

* Official CRL for ANH Stunt is updated.

[NoVATie[Admin]]

Interesting results, not a lot of votes on some of those :-/

[TK bondservnt[501st]]

I think that polls should have large response numbers from the detachment to be valid.

 

these polls should be sent out in e-mails to every trooper in the whole detachment and

 

votes should be cast from almost "every" member to even be considered the official

 

binding opinion of the detachment.

 

polls with low numbers like these are not very professional for a vote.

 

ah... non cannon events, here I come!

Edited August 26, 2010 by TK Bondservnt 2392

[Daetrin[Admin]]

Polls are sent out to every member. We posted them as announcements, put them in the newsletter etc.

 

Some polls get a lot of traffic, others don't.

 

Also, any poll regarding CRL's are binding in that it's our (FISD) recommendation to the LMO who has final authority as to what's on the CRL's, and can simply ignore or modify our suggestion if they so choose.

 

Other polls (EIB, etc.) are internal only and can't be over-ridden by the LMO.

[crypto]

Polls are sent out to every member. We posted them as announcements, put them in the newsletter etc.

 

Just letting you know, I never received any email about polls. And only rarely do I get the newsletter.

[TK5066]

Seems my space pack is good to go, outstanding. Thanks to all who voted, and put both the spacepacks in consideration when voting. Thanks to all.